How HomesOkay cracked SEO + paid as one growth engine.
HomesOkay ran SEO and paid in separate silos that competed for the same queries. We unified them into one keyword-and-intent engine — tripling organic traffic and cutting blended CAC 41% in six months.
HomesOkay was paying for clicks it could have earned, and ranking for terms it was also bidding on. The brief: stop the cannibalization and build one system where SEO and paid share intelligence.
Organic and paid teams worked from different keyword lists and never shared conversion data. Paid spend propped up pages that should have ranked organically, and content targeted terms with no commercial intent.
We built a single intent-mapped keyword universe, used paid data to prioritize content, and let organic take over head terms while paid covered gaps and high-intent long-tail. Shared conversion tracking made the trade-offs visible.
How it actually shipped.
- Phase 1Month 1
Intent mapping
Built one keyword universe mapped to funnel stage and commercial intent.
SEOStrategy - Phase 2Months 1–2
Shared tracking
Unified conversion tracking across organic and paid for true attribution.
Analytics - Phase 3Months 2–4
Content + technical SEO
Shipped intent-led content and fixed technical issues throttling crawl.
SEOContent - Phase 4Months 4–6
Paid rebalancing
Shifted paid budget off cannibalized terms toward true gaps.
Performance Marketing
What changed for HomesOkay.
Removing overlap and rebalancing budget cut acquisition cost.
Non-brand organic sessions tripled in six months.
More qualified leads on the same total budget.
Captured top positions for the highest-value queries.
“We were competing against ourselves and didn't know it. Treating SEO and paid as one engine changed our entire unit economics.”
Lessons that transfer.
Silos cannibalize
Separate SEO and paid teams bid against their own rankings.
Share the data
One conversion source made every trade-off obvious.
Intent over volume
Commercial intent, not traffic, drives CAC.
Let organic own head terms
Free the paid budget for genuine gaps.
Want results like HomesOkay's?
Tell us your goals — we'll come back with a custom plan in 24 hours.